Their Argument(s): Movies like Beauty and the Beast and Snow White are about love conquering all, and how good will triumph.
My Argument: Although they seem harmless on the surface, I argue that Disney movies like Beauty and the Beast and Snow White send harmful messages to young girls and reinforce negative cultural ideas about women.
Topics supporting my argument: (The movies...)
- Show women engaging in unsafe behavior
- Show women in abusive/oppressive situations
- Reinforce ideas about physical beauty being the only value women have.
- Unsafe situations:
- Snow wandering around, going into strange houses, talking to strange women.
- When she does these things, she seems to have no notion of how unsafe they are, and is incapable of rescuing herself.
- Abusive situations:
- Belle held captive by the Beast
- He threatens to starve her
- He is violent and frightening.
- (In Snow White she is forced to be the housekeeper in her own home, and then to a bunch of strange men.)
- Physical beauty:
- B&TB is "about" how we should look past the surface
- But Belle is beautiful (the movie tells us repeatedly)
- Her beauty is why Beast keeps her, and *then* he sees her kindness. For him, she sees his kindness first.
- Physical beauty 2:
- Good looks "save" Snow.
- The huntsman who can't bring himself to kill her.
- The dwarfs take her in.
- The prince kisses her awake.
- Beauty is so important to women it's worth killing over: the queen is so jealous of another women being prettier that she's willing to have her murdered over it.
No comments:
Post a Comment